The Companies Law
Ο περί Εταιρειών Νόμος
Objection to confirmation of the proposals by the Court
Amendments: 62(Ι)/2015, 213(I)/2022
Original source · 2026-09-17
▶Show summaryHide summary
In brief
This article outlines the specific grounds on which various parties can object to a court's confirmation of compromise or settlement proposals. It distinguishes between objections raised by any affected party and those raised by a party who initially voted in favor of the proposals. If the Court finds an objection valid, it can issue any appropriate order, including setting aside a meeting's decision and reconvening it. The Court's ability to rule on the valuation of a 's business is specifically limited to objections concerning the "creditors' interest test" or certain conditions for confirming proposals.
What the law establishes
An affected party can object to the Court confirming proposals during a hearing as provided by article 202KE. The grounds for objection are specified in part 1 of the main article, including:
- Material irregularity during or related to the meeting referred to in article 202KD.
- Proposals accepted due to improper means.
- Proposals submitted for an improper purpose.
- Proposals unfairly affecting the objector's interests.
- Failure to satisfy the "creditors' interest test".
- Failure to satisfy the condition in point (ii) of point (b) of part 4A of article 202KE.
The Court can only decide on a 's business valuation if an objecting affected party raises concerns based on the "creditors' interest test" from point (e) of part 1 of the main article or the specific condition from point (f) of part 1 of the main article, which refers to point (ii) of point (b) of part 4A of article 202KE.
A party who initially voted for the proposals can only object if acceptance was obtained through improper means, or if they later learned the proposals were for an improper purpose as per part 2 of the main article.
If the Court upholds an objection, it can issue any suitable order, including setting aside the decision of any meeting and reconvening it, as stated in part 3 of the main article.
This main article functions within the framework of article 202KE, which details the Court's process for confirming proposals. As per part 2 of article 202KE, have the right to appear and be heard at the confirmation hearing. Part 3 of article 202KE outlines the Court's power to confirm, confirm with modifications, or refuse proposals, considering factors such as fairness, equity, and business continuity. Part 4 of article 202KE sets conditions for confirmation, generally requiring acceptance by each class of as specified in part 3 of article 202KD. However, part 4A of article 202KE allows for confirmation even without unanimous class acceptance under specific circumstances. The "creditors' interest test" mentioned as a ground for objection in point (e) of part 1 of the main article is elaborated in point (iii) of point (b) of part 4 of article 202KE, where it is a condition for the Court to be satisfied before confirming proposals when there are dissenting creditors.
In practice
(such as creditors and members) have a legal avenue to challenge compromise or settlement proposals presented to the Court for confirmation under the provisions of this article. This mechanism serves as a safeguard against proposals that are procedurally flawed (e.g., irregularities in meetings as described in point (a) of part 1 of the main article, referring to article 202KD), unfairly prejudicial (e.g., point (d) of part 1 of the main article), or fail to meet fundamental tests like the "creditors' interest test" (point (e) of part 1 of the main article, which relates to point (iii) of point (b) of part 4 of article 202KE).
Even parties who initially voted in favor of the proposals can object if they discover issues such as impropriety or an improper purpose after their vote as outlined in part 2 of the main article. The Court's power to intervene, including ordering new meetings as per part 3 of the main article, ensures the process remains fair and transparent. The specific provision regarding valuation decisions (part 1A of the main article) underscores that significant objections concerning the "creditors' interest test" or the conditions for confirming proposals without unanimous class approval (as specified in part 4A of article 202KE) can trigger a Court assessment of the 's value, which is critical for ensuring fairness to creditors.
▶Show full textHide full text
1. At the hearing in accordance with the provisions of section 202KE, an affected party may object to their confirmation by the Court, on any of the following grounds:
a) That there was some material irregularity at or in relation to the meeting to which section 202KD applies, (β) that the acceptance of the proposals by the meeting was secured by improper means, (γ) that the proposals were proposed for an improper purpose, (δ) that the proposals unfairly prejudice the interests of the objector, (ε) that the best-interests-of-creditors test is not satisfied;
f) that the condition of subparagraph (ii) of paragraph (b) of subsection (4A) of section 202KE is not satisfied.
1A. The Court may make a decision regarding the valuation of the 's business only in the case of an objection against a plan by a dissenting affected party on grounds provided for in paragraphs (e) and/or
f) of subsection .
2. Any person who voted in favour of the acceptance of the proposals may object to their confirmation by the Court only on the following grounds -
a) that such acceptance was secured by improper means, or
b) that after voting in favour of the acceptance of the proposals, they became aware that the proposals were presented for an improper purpose.
3. In the event that the Court upholds an objection in accordance with this section, the Court may make such order as it deems fit, including an order setting aside the decision of any meeting and reconvening any meeting.
▶Original (Greek)Hide original
1. Κατά την ακρόαση σύμφωνα με τις διατάξεις του άρθρου , θιγόμενο μέρος, δύναται να φέρει ένσταση στην επιβεβαίωσή τους από το από το Δικαστήριο, βάσει οποιουδήποτε από τους πιο κάτω λόγους:
α) Ότι υπήρξε κάποια ουσιαστική παρατυπία κατά ή σε σχέση με την συνέλευση στην οποία εφαρμόζεται το άρθρο , (β) ότι η αποδοχή των προτάσεων από τη συνέλευση εξασφαλίστηκε με ακατάλληλα μέσα, (γ) ότι οι προτάσεις προτάθηκαν για ακατάλληλο σκοπό, (δ) ότι οι προτάσεις επηρεάζουν με άδικο τρόπο τα συμφέροντα αυτού που ενίσταται, (ε) ότι το δεν ικανοποιείται·
στ) ότι η προϋπόθεση της υποπαραγράφου
ii) της παραγράφου
β) του εδαφίου (4Α) του άρθρου δεν ικανοποιείται. 1Α. Το Δικαστήριο δύναται να λάβει απόφαση σχετικά με την αποτίμηση της επιχείρησης της εταιρείας μόνον σε περίπτωση ένστασης κατά σχεδίου διακανονισμού από διαφωνούν θιγόμενο μέρος με βάση προβλεπόμενους στις παραγράφους
ε) και/ή
στ) του εδαφίου λόγους.
2. Οποιοδήποτε πρόσωπο, το οποίο ψήφισε υπέρ της αποδοχής των προτάσεων δύναται να φέρει ένσταση στην επιβεβαίωσή τους από το Δικαστήριο μόνο για τους πιο κάτω λόγους -
α) ότι η αποδοχή αυτή εξασφαλίστηκε με ακατάλληλα μέσα, ή
β) ότι αφού ψήφισε υπέρ της αποδοχής των προτάσεων, έλαβε γνώση ότι οι προτάσεις παρουσιάστηκαν για ακατάλληλο σκοπό.
3. Σε περίπτωση που το Δικαστήριο επικυρώνει ένσταση σύμφωνα με το παρόν άρθρο, το Δικαστήριο δύναται να εκδώσει, τέτοιο διάταγμα, ως θεωρεί πρέπον, συμπεριλαμβανομένου διατάγματος παραμερισμού της απόφασης οποιασδήποτε συνέλευσης και επανασύγκλησης οποιασδήποτε συνέλευσης.
This information is for general guidance only and is not legal advice. Check the primary source and consult a lawyer where necessary.